Skip to main content

Table 1 Mean squared prediction error (MSPE) for the LASSO, Bayesian LASSO (BLASSO), genomic BLUP (GBLUP), reproducing kernel Hilbert space (RKHS) regression, random forests (RF) and Bayesian additive regression trees (BART) methods evaluated on the simulated original QTLMAS2010 data

From: Genome-wide prediction using Bayesian additive regression trees

Method

Mean squared prediction error (MSPE)

LASSO

 minMSE

62.020

 minMSE + 1SE

63.404

BLASSO

66.209

GBLUP

66.949

RKHS

 

 \(h = 0.05\)

66.910

 \(h = 0.1\)

66.821

 \(h = 0.25\)

67.200

RF

M = 10

M = 25

M = 50

M = 100

M = 200

M = 400

M = 600

 

82.108

79.772

77.794

77.274

77.149

76.141

76.419

BART

M = 10

M = 25

M = 50

M = 100

M = 200

M = 400

M = 600

 \(q = 0.9\)

 \(\kappa\) = 2

76.231

69.974

65.703

64.967

64.324

64.213

64.574

 \(\kappa\) = 3

71.325

68.537

66.755

63.772

62.782

62.919

63.476

 \(\kappa\) = 4

79.264

66.554

66.376

63.596

62.595

63.119

63.790

 \(\kappa\) = 5

72.344

70.608

65.467

62.705

62.715

63.997

64.982

 \(q = 0.95\)

 \(\kappa\) = 2

78.656

76.734

68.282

64.126

64.218

63.697

64.566

 \(\kappa\) = 3

74.893

68.379

64.858

63.762

62.884

63.108

63.402

 \(\kappa\) = 4

74.128

66.817

64.788

63.836

62.596

63.175

63.807

 \(\kappa\) = 5

76.757

66.284

64.512

62.648

62.823

63.912

64.976

  1. The lowest MSPE obtained with each method is highlighted in italics. M is the number of trees for RF and BART, and \(q\) and \(\kappa\) are hyperparameters of the BART priors. The stopping criteria for the regularization coefficient λ in LASSO were obtained based on tenfold cross-validation both at minimum MSE and minimum MSE plus 1 standard error [42]