Skip to main content

Table 3 Method of assessing effects of selection on GHG emissions from the beef cattle production system

From: Methods and consequences of including reduction in greenhouse gas emission in beef cattle multiple-trait selection

Performance measure

Performance levela

After selection

 Young animal pasture feed (PFA), MJ

PFB + Σ(∆PFi)

 Young animal feedlot feed (FFA), MJ

FFB + Σ(∆FFi)

 Young animal total feed, MJ

PFA + FFA

 Cow pasture feed (CFA), MJ

CFB + Σ(∆CFi)

 Total feed (TFA), MJ

PFA + FFA + CFA

 Young animal GHG emission at pasture (PGA), g

PGB + Σ(∆PGi)

 Young animal GHG emission in the feedlot (FGA), g

FGB + Σ(∆FGi)

 Young animal total GHG emission, g

PGA + FGA

 Cow GHG emission at pasture (CGA), g

CGB + Σ(∆CGi)

 Total GHG emission (TGA), g

PGA + FGA + CGA

Effects of selection

Before selection (XB)

After selection (XA)

% Change

Total productb, kg

KGB

KGA

(XA/XB × 100) − 100

Total feed, MJ

TFB

TFA

Total GHG emissions, g

TGB

TGA

$ net returnc,d,e

DNRB

DNRB + Σ(VTCi)

Product per unit of feede, kg/MJ

KGB/TFB

KGA/TFA

GHG per unit of product, g/kg

TGB/KGB

TGA/KGA

GHG per unit of feed, g/MJ

TGB/TFB

TGA/TFA

$ net return per unit of feede, $/MJ

DNRB/TFB

[DNRB + Σ(VTCi)]/TFA

$ net return per unit of GHGe, $/g

DNRB/TGB

[DNRB + Σ(VTCi)]/TGA

  1. aIncludes level of performance of the production system before selection (per cow): young animal pasture feed (PFB), young animal feedlot feed (FFB), total young animal feed (PFB + FFB), cow pasture feed (CFB), total feed (TFB), young animal GHG emission at pasture (PGB), young animal GHG emission in the feedlot (FGB), cow GHG emission (CGB), total GHG emission (TGB), total product (KGB), $ net return (DNRB)
  2. bExpressed as equivalent steer beef, before (KGB) and after (KGA) selection
  3. cFeed price before selection is based on a land value of $400/DSE (feed required by a 50 kg dry sheep (9.7 MJ/head/d) [20]), leased at 7% p.a. [21]
  4. dTotal value of trait change, Σ(VTCi) = Σ(∆Ti from selection x economic value of Ti); ∆Ti assumes that selection intensity, i is equal to1
  5. eUses total feed, before and after selection, assessed over the limited feed period